During a match of EDH - the opponent has a Contamination out. At the beginning of your upkeep, sacrifice Contamination unless you sacrifice a creature.If a land is tapped for mana, it produces (Black) instead of any other type and amount.They really need to do another print run of jumpstart. On my turn, i play a Gauntlet of Power and call blue, am i then allowed to play an Aetherplasm (anything, really) due to getting the blue from GoP or does Contamination nullify that mana too? 18 5

The Gauntlet will see that you're tapping the Mountain for red mana and it will trigger. Whoops, missed the word 'instead' when reading Hall of Gemstone, you are correct EllE, the affected player gets to choose. It doesn't care that Contamination's replacement effect made that mana black instead of red (and yes, that is an [O]fficial answer). The card pool thus roughly spans the period inbetween the formats 93/94 and Modern. 43 Rules: At the beginning of your upkeep, sacrifice Contamination unless you sacrifice a creature. You may have up to one chosen companion for each game. 2 Contamination, on the other hand, warps your entire deck around it. 5 "To face death, that's nothing much. 3 is average. That means millions if different interactions. Rules Q&A; Community; Card search; Deck search; login; sign-up; Contamination Enchantment. So my girlfriend and I are playing EDH on MWS and came across this scenario:
This site © 2020 TappedOut.net, LLC The companion ability lists a deckbuilding rule. The head judge of your tournament (if this somehow actually ever came up, which I've never seen) can make a final ruling that will stand for that event. COMPREHENSIVE RULES. It doesn't care that Contamination's replacement effect made that mana black instead of red (and yes, that is an [O]fficial answer). "Abstract concepts of perfect judging run headlong into the realities of how people play the game." All the same rules apply to it.)

If you are seriously concerned, announce how that ruling will work before the event for your tournaments, so nobody is surprised. Reviews Below: David Fanany Player since 1995. Mirrodin's caretaker Memnarch slowly went mad, abducting mortals from across the Multiverse to populate the plane. dnLL. I never said I liked it, but I can't give you an answer that doesn't exist, nor can I force one into existence. Browse through cards from Magic's entire history. Ads by Fandom. It doesn't ask much (except for basics and red mana), and often just gets free wins. You choose whether to sacrifice a creature or not on resolution. The Gauntlet doesn't take replacement effects into account. PDF. This site © 2020 TappedOut.net, LLC Why hasn't it been linked in the past? Do you think going for a land-destruction or Also I'm curious why you're running horn of greed over something like Would your playgroup be mad if you ran something like Since this build has a cumulative effect on opponent’s resources, I feel as though It might be kind of a difficult card to work around but your description really reminded me of Magic the Gathering, FNM is TM and copyright Wizards of the Coast, Inc, a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc. All rights reserved. 43 The Comprehensive Rules of Magic is a reference document that holds all of the rules and possible corner cases found in Magic. Following his loyal hound, Mowu, Yanggu traveled until he came to the village of the powerful Jiuli Clan.
If your starting deck follows that rule, then the creature can serve as your chosen companion. Contamination Enchantment. As I said, though, nobody has ever seen this happen in a sanctioned tournament to my knowledge, so I wouldn't spend too much time fretting about it. - Toby Elliott (papa_funk) My Type 4 Stack-- DCI Documents-- Comp Rules #7 Feb 5, 2014. dnLL. Setting a land’s subtype doesn’t add or remove any card types (such as creature) or supertypes (such as basic, legendary, and snow) the land may have. ) This site is I've already heard from numerous sources that the two enchantments are replacement effects, so that regardless of what the land taps for, the enchants replace it with Black. Correct?

You can choose to not sacrifice even if you no longer control Contamination on resolution. TXT Contamination does work if it resolves, but more often than not it's just a bit too slow to set up (not to mention it doesn't stop Fireblast). Nathan Long is an official Wizards NetRep, and as such is authorized to make [O]fficial rulings (usually after he consults with the rules team in the case of unclear rulings).